Focused 100% On Education Law Matters

Will a Professionalism Finding Show Up in Your MSPE? What Medical Students Should Know

by

For medical students, a professionalism case does not always end when the school decides it. It can follow the student into residency applications through the Medical Student Performance Evaluation, or MSPE, often called the Dean’s Letter. The AAMC’s recommendations for the MSPE state that the Academic History section includes information, based on school-specific policies, about any adverse actions imposed on the student by the medical school or its parent institution. Some schools are explicit: Northeast Ohio Medical University’s policy states that if its academic and professional progress committee imposes an adverse action, such as academic or professionalism probation, the MSPE must disclose it.

Each medical school writes its own MSPE policy within the AAMC’s recommendations, and those policies change. This article describes common patterns drawn from published policies.

What the MSPE Is

The MSPE is an evaluation of a student’s performance in medical school, prepared by the school for residency applications. Medical schools describe it as an evaluation rather than a letter of recommendation, and Campbell University’s medical school notes that the MSPE may contain negative as well as positive aspects of a student’s performance.

Where Professionalism Appears

The AAMC recommends that the MSPE include an Academic History section asking whether the student was the recipient of any adverse actions, and that the Academic Progress section describe how the school defines and assesses professionalism. Hofstra’s medical school, for example, notes that negative professionalism findings, if any, are reported in the professional performance portion of the MSPE.

Timing Matters

Because the MSPE is prepared on a fixed schedule for residency applications, the timing of a case can matter. Northeast Ohio Medical University’s policy states that if an adverse action is imposed after the MSPE is released, the school will amend the MSPE.

Reviewing the MSPE

Medical schools generally allow students to review their MSPE before it is released. As one school’s policy notes, accreditation standards require medical schools to have procedures that allow students to review and challenge their educational records, including the MSPE, if they believe the information is inaccurate, misleading, or inappropriate.

Why the Underlying Case Matters

Since the outcome of a professionalism case can determine what appears in the MSPE, how the case is resolved can affect residency applications. The stakes in medical school discipline are covered in dismissed from medical school, and exam-related allegations that often arise in medical programs are discussed in flagged by ExamSoft? and accused of cheating on a licensing or board exam?

Frequently Asked Questions

Will professionalism probation appear in my MSPE?
It can. The AAMC recommends that the MSPE include adverse actions imposed by the medical school, and some schools state that professionalism probation must be disclosed.

What is the MSPE?
The Medical Student Performance Evaluation, often called the Dean’s Letter, is a medical school’s evaluation of a student’s performance, used in residency applications.

What if an adverse action happens after my MSPE is released?
Some schools, such as Northeast Ohio Medical University, state that they will amend the MSPE.

Can I review my MSPE before it is sent?
Medical schools generally allow students to review their MSPE and have procedures to challenge inaccurate or misleading information.

Getting Help With a Professionalism Case

Richard Asselta, a student defense attorney, serves as an advisor to medical students in professionalism and academic processes nationwide. Call 855-338-5299 or learn more about Richard Asselta.

General information, not legal advice. MSPE policies vary by school and change; outcomes depend on each case’s facts and the rules in effect.

Archives

Categories